Restorative & Aesthetic Dentistry

Pain to pain-free: Journey of local anesthetic delivery systems in dentistry

Abstract No oral surgical procedure can be done without local anesthesia. The main aim of local anesthesia is to ensure that dental procedures cause a minimal...

Dr. Zainab Rangwala

Dr. Zainab Rangwala

Chief Dentist · GDCHJ

6 min read198,872 views
  • jet injectors
  • vibration devices
  • professional education
  • pain management
  • dentistry
  • injection techniques
  • local anesthesia
  • computer-controlled delivery
  • Restorative & Aesthetic Dentistry
  • Clinical & Academic Article

Abstract

No oral surgical procedure can be done without local anesthesia. The main aim of local anesthesia is to ensure that dental procedures cause a minimal amount of pain to the patient. But the conventional way of delivering local anesthesia using a syringe and needle appears to increase the patient’s apprehension and anxiety even before the commencement of dental procedures. This has given rise to a number of anaesthesia delivery systems, briefly explained in this article.

Introduction

No matter how perfect your margins are or how secure your occlusal placement is, patients won't understand its benefit immediately. But, if you make them jump when you inject them with LA, they will most definitely remember that! So apart from the best clinical work, it is vital to focus on the most uncomfortable part of our practice - dental anesthesia.

Local anesthesia was discovered in the year 1884 by Karl Kolle. Since Cook developed the current dental syringe about 150 years ago, significant advancements in anesthetic delivery systems have been made. Despite the fact that the standard aspirating syringe is still the most popular way of administering local anesthetics, more recent technologies have been discovered that can help the dentist provide more significant pain relief with less painful injections and minimal side effects. This is of more significance for palatal injections especially because it causes the greatest discomfort to the patients.

The majority of research efforts are aimed at the improvement of anesthetic drugs, delivery systems, and associated techniques.

Computer-controlled Local Anesthetic Delivery Systems (CCLAD)

It is essential to precisely maintain a slower speed and constant rate of injection of local anesthesia in order to avoid any major discomfort to the patient. This was not always possible using conventional syringes, which led to the development of this new delivery system that controls the rate and speed using computer technology.

The development of local anesthetic delivery devices that used computer technology to regulate the anesthetic solution's rate of flow through the needle started in the middle of the 1990s. Numerous clinical investigations using CCLAD devices in dentistry have shown that the increased syringe control and the regulated LA medication flow rates result in a noticeably better injection experience.

Before selecting an appropriate system, it is crucial for the operator to consider the system's design, which takes into account factors like weight, infection control, speed and mode of drug injection, the likelihood of aspiration, etc.

The Wand system (launched in 1997) was the first CCLAD used, and later variations included Wand Plus and CompuDent. Another gadget that differs from the Wand system in that it lacks foot control is the Comfort Control Syringe (launched in 2001).

Advantages:

  • Greater tactile sensation
  • Consistent flow rates
  • Significantly improved injection experience (a two to a three-fold reduction in pain perception)

Drawbacks:

  • Some CCLAD systems and bulkier and more cumbersome to be handled by the dental professionals

Examples :

  • The Wand system
  • Wand Plus and
  • CompuDent.
  • Comfort Control Syringe
  • Single Tooth Anesthesia (STA™)

NOTE: Single Tooth Anesthesia (STA™) uses dynamic pressure sensing technology (DPS) assures that the needle tip is in the proper place and has not moved outside of this area through verbal clues, visual displays, and audio signals. This is especially useful for PDL injections.

Vibrotactile Devices

These devices used the gate control theory of pain management to reduce the fear of needles in patients by simultaneous activation of nerve fibers through the use of vibration.

It’s action is based on the fact that the vibration message is carried to the brain through insulated nerves and the pain message through smaller uninsulated nerves. The insulated nerves overrule the smaller uninsulated nerves, hence the patient feels the vibration more than the pain.

Advantages:

  • Suggested reduction in pain perception

Drawbacks:

  • Lack of proper research regarding the efficacy in reducing pain and fear

Examples:

  • VibraJect
  • DentalVibe
  • Accupal

Jet Injectors

The idea behind jet injection technology is to use a mechanical energy source to generate pressure strong enough to force a liquid drug through a very small opening and into the subcutaneous tissues without the use of a needle.

Free for members

Keep reading — it's free

The rest of this article is open to DentalReach members. Create a free account, or sign in, and every article on the site opens in full.

One email on Tuesdays: new articles, discussions, events and jobs. Unsubscribe in one click.

Topics

References

  1. [1]Young DA, Nový BB, Zeller GG, et al.. The American Dental Association Caries Classification System for Clinical Practice Journal of the American Dental Association. 2015. DOI: 10.1016/j.adaj.2014.11.018. Available at: source
  2. [2]Miao C, Yang X, Wong MCM, et al.. Rubber dam isolation for restorative treatment in dental patients Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2021. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD009858.pub3. Available at: source

Written by

Dr. Zainab Rangwala

Dr. Zainab Rangwala

Chief Dentist · GDCHJ

With over 12 years of clinical experience, Dr. Zainab Rangwala brings a unique blend of clinical expertise and communication excellence to her role as the Media and PR Head at DentalReach. Passionate about bridging the gap between dentistry and digital communication, she plays a key role in shaping the platform’s voice and outreach.

Have a question about this article?

Ask DentalReach for a sourced answer from the library. It cannot provide personal medical advice.

Ask about this article