Restorative & Aesthetic Dentistry

19 Incredible Rubber Dam Alternatives: YOU MUST KNOW about

A practical comparison of alternative dental isolation methods, their limitations and situations where rubber dam isolation remains the clinical standard.

Dr. Rockson Samuel

Dr. Rockson Samuel

Founder & Chief Dentist · Indira Dental Clinic; DentalReach

9 min read78,341 views
  • isolation techniques
  • paediatric dentistry
  • moisture control
  • erosion restoration
  • dental isolation
  • clinical technique
  • restorative dentistry
  • dental materials
  • retraction
  • cervical abrasion
The use of Rubber Dam makes Dentistry not only easier for the Dentists but also helps a lot in getting better results. There are a lot of Rubber Dam Alternatives too that we miss out on. Adhesive techniques are comparatively more sensitive than conventional ones. Here we will focus on atraumatic technique of restoring cervical abrasion-erosion and carious lesions. It is absolutely mandatory to isolate the operatory field to use an alternative placement of sequence in the dental rubber dam. This is where the use of Rubber Dam Alternatives/Dental Dam Alternatives comes into the picture. The environment should be suitable enough to be visible, adequate space for instrumentation, easily accessible, moisture controllable for insertion as well as manipulation of dental restorative materials. It should be isolated from soft tissue and moisture including tongue, gingiva, lips and cheeks, blood, saliva and gingival crevicular fluid.

The aim of Dental Dam isolation

Control of moisture

During the operation, control of moisture is required to prevent debris restorative and hand piece spray from being aspirated by the patient. It refers in the operating field excluding saliva, gingival bleeding and sulcular fluid. Operative dentistry cannot be applied unless the moisture in the oral cavity is controlled properly for execution. Absorbents, suction devices and rubber dam help in controlling the moisture.

Access and retraction

This provides maximal exposure during the operation which includes maintaining an open mouth and retracting or depressing tongue, gingival tissue, cheeks and lips. Retraction cord, absorbents, rubber dam, mouth prop, high volume evacuator are useful for access and retraction. The restorative procedure cannot be managed with ease in case of improper access and retraction.

Prevention of harm

An important aspect to be considered is to prevent the patient from being harmed and members of health professions. The axiom taught is “DO NO HARM”, it is basically an awareness to prevent the patients from being protected from harm. The main aspect of prevention of harm along with retraction and moisture control are mouth props (occasional use), absorbents, suction devices and rubber dams.

Classification: Rubber Dam Isolation

Moisture isolation

Direct method

Rubber dam, cotton roll and holder, pieces of gauze, absorbent wafers, suction devices and gingival retraction devices.

Indirect method

Comfortable position and relaxed surrounding for the patient, local anaesthesia, muscle relaxants, antisialagogue and anti-anxiety medication.

Rubber Dam/Dental Dam

It has good visibility and adequate access to the operating field, patient protection and management.

History

On 15th March 1864, Dr Sanford Christine Barnum Connecticut valley, dental society. Dr JF Hadson 1870, seven types of clamps, no forceps used. Dr Tees 1870, festooned clamps Dr Elliot 1878, designed clamp forceps Ainsworth 1879, rubber dam punch Dr Hickmans 1880, lipped clamps In 1890, clamps with holes. Rubber dam frame introduced a metal Fernald's frame in early 20th century.

Advantages

  • Access and visibility
  • Clean and dry operating field
  • Protects operator and patient
  • Psychologically more relaxing
  • Reduces risk of cross-contamination and objection by the patient

Disadvantages

  • Minor changes in cervical cementum and marginal gingiva during clamp removal
  • Time consuming and patient willingness
  • Ceramic crowns may fracture in case of clamps, gripped to the margins
  • Metal crown margins show defects at a microscopic level following removal of the clamp

Indications

Bleaching, endodontic treatment and caustic chemicals.

Contraindications

In fixed orthodontic appliances, a newly erupted tooth has been found where the clamp does not retain due to physiological resistance and allergies.

Rubber Dam Alternatives

Beside the usage of Rubber Dam there are a lot of other benefits of using Dental Dam Alternatives. These Rubber Dam Alternatives are listed below.

1. Cotton rolls and holders

When rubber dam application is impractical, absorbent in case of moisture helps in minimally retracting soft tissues. Manually rolled as well as prefabricated with smooth and woven maybe be employed.

2. Fluid absorbing materials:

Cotton rolls are used in association with anaesthesia will provide acceptable dryness for procedures such as examination, topical fluoride application, sealant placement, impression taking, cementation. Cotton roll holders in which cotton rolls can be placed into position and with commercial devices stabilised withholding it.

Advantages

Visibility and accessibility improvements in the working area and it provides more retraction.

Disadvantages

It is time-consuming as it has to be constantly changed.

Techniques used for application

  1. Maxillary anterior area isolation
  2. Labial frenum on either side, a small sized roll is placed
  3. Mandibular anterior area isolation
  4. Mandibular labial frenum along with a lingual sulcus on either side small sized rolls

3. Absorbent Pads/Cellulose wafers

Dry aid/parotid shield Silver dri aid: It reflects light for improved visibility in which laminated side prevents soak through it.

4. Gauze pieces

2” * 2” (5*5 cm) The functionality is same as cotton rolls and also delicate tissue is better tolerated by it.

5. Evacuation system

There are two types of Evacuation system
  • High vacuum evacuation system
  • Low vacuum evacuation system

6. Debris and fluid evacuation equipment

High volume evacuation: Metallic autoclavable tips and disposable plastic. Approximately 150 ml of water per second, it is also more efficient.

Advantages

In the working site it removes shavings of the tooth and restorative material as well as other debris to remove the toxic material. Washing is avoided with intermittent rinsing and decreases the time of treatment.

7. Saliva Ejector

  • Metallic autoclavable tips
  • Disposable plastic

Placement

It is not directly in contact with tissues; saliva ejectors should be placed with their tips on the floor of the mouth.

Free for members

Keep reading — it's free

The rest of this article is open to DentalReach members. Create a free account, or sign in, and every article on the site opens in full.

One email on Tuesdays: new articles, discussions, events and jobs. Unsubscribe in one click.

Topics

References

  1. [1]Miao C, Yang X, Wong MCM, et al.. Rubber dam isolation for restorative treatment in dental patients Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2021. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD009858.pub3. Available at: source
  2. [2]Cochrane Oral Health. Does rubber dam isolation improve restorative treatment outcomes? Cochrane Evidence. 2021. Available at: source

Written by

Dr. Rockson Samuel

Dr. Rockson Samuel

Founder & Chief Dentist · Indira Dental Clinic; DentalReach

Dr. Rockson Samuel is a dental surgeon, healthcare content strategist, and Founder and Chief Dentist of Indira Dental Clinic in Vellore, Tamil Nadu. He provides comprehensive general and family dental care with professional interests in endodontics, implant dentistry, clear aligner therapy, digital dentistry, preventive care and patient education. A graduate of K.G.F. College of Dental Sciences and Hospital under Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, he also has formal training in management and digital marketing. As Community Leader at DentalReach, he contributes to dental publishing, professional education, international media partnerships and the development of evidence-informed resources for dentists.

Have a question about this article?

Ask DentalReach for a sourced answer from the library. It cannot provide personal medical advice.

Ask about this article