– Dr Ketaki Kalele

It is rightly said that every coin has two sides. The same is true for the most favored synthetic used over “eras” in our toothpaste, which is sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) & Paraben!

In this Article

The “toxic two”

They grey sides of the two chemicals have provoked this nomenclature “toxic two”!

1) SLS is a cleaning agent & surfactant found in toothpastes. The USP of the compound is its :

efficiency
low cost
abundance
simplicity of use
ability of “foam” formation which triggers the solubility of plaque & calculus during brushing

As stated by ADA, the foam “cloud” enables the efficient separation of food debris and other accretions stuck to the tooth surfaces, which ultimately are great benefits achieved with single ingredient.

However, recently controversy regarding this “celebrity” ingredient is catching the limelight. The safety concern of SLS is much talked about. According to the National Institute of Health (NIH), SLS is a safe product & the fact of it being a carcinogen is just a rumour. But though not a carcinogen, but SLS is known to aggravate the conditions such as stomatitis & mouth sores/ulcers. 1

2) Paraben, one of the most used preservative in many cosmetics including toothpastes, is banned in many countries including European countries, because of its potential hazards including its role as a potential carcinogen.

Sponsored ad

The “Irritating Stuff”

SLS component is known to cause biochemical protein denaturation which results in a visible desquamation of the mucosal membrane. Researchers have reported that frequent local application of toothpastes containing SLS may cause oral lesions due to absorption of the chemical sublingually or from the mucosa. However, a latest (2020) Brazilian research by Esteves et al. has reported cases of oral mucosal desquamation which were diagnosed as Type IV hypersensitivity to SLS from the toothpastes. Their study reported hypersensitivity even with the lowest concentration of 0.25%, which is far below the permissible levels of 0.5-2%. However, all the patients in their case series were also using alcohol-based mouthwashes, which acts as an additive.

Also read: Topical Fluoride Applications: By Patient & By Dentist

Another case series from Brown et al. has also shown evidences of inflammatory changes & erythematous textures of mucosa in patients using SLS containing toothpastes, which resolved on their own after discontinuation of the toothpastes.

Broadly, though the exclusive role of SLS in causing oral lesions is not much studied & NIH reports the compound safe for use in permissible concentration; still dentists must be aware of its deleterious effects on oral cavity.

SLS induced hypersentivity & desquamation must be kept in mind as differential diagnosis for lesions, including non-specific ulcerations and lichenoid reactions.
It is advisable not to use SLS tooth cleaning products in patients with existing oral conditions and in patients with history of recurrent aphthous ulcers, as the compound is known to aggravate these pre-existing oral conditions.

The “Mimicking Demon”

Paraben compounds including ethyl paraben and methyl paraben are known to mimic the estrogen components which binds to the breast cancer cells and hence cause their multiplication. The research done on breast cancer cells and presence of various derivatives of paraben have shown that 99% breast cancer cells have shown the presence of paraben compounds. This cytotoxic product also has proved to cause other neuroendocrine disorders and local toxicity issues including gingivitis etc.

The “alert” with paraben is because it is easily absorbable into the blood circulation through the oral mucosal membrane (4000-fold more permeability than skin) and penetration into digestive systems (through salivary mucins).

Products for local application which are ‘SLS & Paraben free’ are generally preferred for use. Hence, even dentifrices should be checked, analysed and opinionated by experts just like any other skin, hair or body products.

Also read: Reports of Cracked Teeth Uptick Amid COVID19

Awareness regarding the harmful effects a wrong toothpaste can have on patient’s precious health cannot be underestimated. This especially holds true in this era of reckless advertisements and marketing where there are minimum filters for health safety and hence being professionals, we can prevent the health hazards by at least knowing “What not to prescribe”!!!

References

1) https://www.colgate.com/en-us/oral-health/selecting-dental-products/what-sodium-lauryl-sulfate-is-it-safe

2) Pérez-López D, Varela-Centelles P, García-Pola MJ, Castelo-Baz P, García-Caballero L, Seoane-Romero JM Oral mucosal peeling related to dentifrices and mouthwashes:A systematic review .Med Oral Pathol Oral Cir Bucal 2019;24(4):e452-60.

3) Esteves CV, de Campos WG, Paredes WEB, Nunes FD, Alves FA, Lemos CA. Could sodium lauryl sulfate be an irritant factor in oral mucosal desquamation? Int J Case Rep Images 2020;11:101184Z01CE2020.

4) Brown RS, Smith L, Glascoe AL. Inflammatory reaction of the anterior dorsal tongue presumably to sodium lauryl sulfate within toothpastes: A triple case report. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol 2018;125(2):e17–21. [CrossRef] [Pubmed] ????

5) Ahn G S , Park Y D , Yoo M S. The Exposure Amount of Paraben from Commercial Toothpaste. Int J Clin Prev Dent 2014;10(1):31-36